With many of the new features revealed for the new iPhone, it feels like Apple is just playing catch-up with many of the premium Android handsets available on the market. Take the larger, 4-inch screen size, for example. Clearly this is a response to the trend of Android smartphones including ever-larger screen sizes. Samsung’s Galaxy Note with its 5-inch screen size and Galaxy S III with its 4.8-inch screen size sold like hot cakes and Apple must have been suffering from screen envy. In response, its upsized the iPhone screen to four inches, typical of many Android devices on the market. (Now who is copying who?)

Apple’s iPhone 5 will be the thinnest iPhone yet. (Photo: Apple)

When the iPhone first came out, I didn’t get what all the hype was about.

Before it was even available in Canada, we heard the hype from the U.S. launch about this magical new device that Apple had launched. It was more than just a cell phone – it was a camera, a Web browser, a contact organizer, a music player, and a video player. “So what?”, I thought to myself smugly. “My HTC p4000 can do all of those things, and it has a real keyboard too.”

I was quickly proven wrong about the iPhone. It really did live up to the hype, thanks to the user experience that its elegant hardware design combined with iOS offered over devices based on Windows Mobile 6. But after Apple’s launch of the iPhone 5 yesterday – which is actually the sixth iteration of the device – I am left thinking pretty much the same thing. So what?

With many of the new features revealed for the new iPhone, it feels like Apple is just playing catch-up with many of the premium Android handsets available on the market. Take the larger, 4-inch screen size, for example. Clearly this is a response to the trend of Android smartphones including ever-larger screen sizes. Samsung’s Galaxy Note with its 5-inch screen size and Galaxy S III with its 4.8-inch screen size sold like hot cakes and Apple must have been suffering from screen envy. In response, its upsized the iPhone screen to four inches, typical of many Android devices on the market. (Now who is copying who?)

The other big features on the iPhone 5 flaunted yesterday include an LTE cellular radio so it can connect with modern high-speed networks, and an 8-megapixel camera that is much unchanged from the iPhone 4S. The LTE connectivity is already available in many devices on the market and is an obvious upgrade to keep pace with wireless broadband. The camera is comparable to many other 8 megapixel cameras capable of HD video capture.

Slideshow - Extend your iPhone with 11 great gadgets

Apple is still leaving out standard features offered by many Android phones. The iPhone 5 won’t include near-field communications (NFC) chip technology, meaning it can’t be used as a tap-to-pay mobile wallet. Nor can it be tapped to NFC tags to conveniently trigger certain device functions, the way that the just-announced Nokia Lumia 920 will start streaming its audio over a JBL speaker when you simply tap it with the phone. Apple still refuses to allow for external memory card slots to further expand storage.

Still, just as the original iPhone was so clearly superior to my HTC p4000 smartphone in 2007, the iPhone 5’s secret sauce may be in the user experience. Not a list of features that may or may not be included in other smartphones, but a cumulative effect resulting from design and execution. As Apple would say, a smartphone that “just works.”

Come Sept. 21, I won’t be surprised this time if the sales live up to the hype.

Share on LinkedIn Comment on this article Share with Google+
Around the Web
  • Stuntman

    The secret sauce is in their marketing. No other smartphone manufacturer does a better job at marketing than Apple.

    As for a smartphone that “just works”, my personal experience with the iPhone differs. I have had to deal with various issues with iPhones in my family. They have their share of issues just like any other smartphone.

    One thing about the user experience is that the iPhone hides any issues that it encounters. Any force close will bring you back to the home screen and makes the user think that they did something wrong and the problem is with the user and not the iPhone. On Android smartphones, the phone actually tells the user that there is an issue.

  • John

    The lackluster Apple iPhone 5 introduction has provided a nice window for a BlackBerry comeback. The new BB10 phones will at least have some “wow” factor.

  • sara

    As a customer who has, purely urged by trends, jumped back and forth from android to iPhone android to iPhone for a long time I mist say how superior android is. I’ve been disappointed over and over again with the iPhone yet I let myself believe all the hype and find myself purchasing the newest one. I just got rid if the iPhone 4s for the Samsung Galaxy S3 and have NO intention, what so ever, to purchase the new iPhone 5, even with mounting trends. The iPhone’s I have owned have all been slow, they have small screens and I’ve just been very disappointed with them in general. Long story short Android is the way to go!