Top five under $500 ultra-portable notebooks square off

Acer Aspire One Mini-Notebook
Considering its bargain price of $349, the Acer Aspire One is a steal–until you realize that you want the $100 six-cell battery. The included three-cell battery lasted only 2 hours, 16 minutes in our tests.

Acer’s well-constructed, elegant entry is roughly the same size as the Lenovo IdeaPad S10. It weighs 2 pounds, about the same as the tiny Dell Mini 9.

The Windows XP version has a 120GB hard drive and an excellent keyboard. Our WorldBench 6 test results placed the Aspire One toward the back of the Atom-based pack with a score of 34. The Windows-based Aspire One did easily outpace HP’s 2133, whose Via C-7M CPU led it to an anemic mark of 26; but it fell well short of the Lenovo S10’s surprising score of 41.

A couple other issues with the Aspire One are a letdown. The mouse buttons flank the touchpad, a design that can make navigating documents difficult. A more minor issue is software bloat: Our test system came preinstalled with a 60-day trial of Microsoft Office, McAfee Security Center, and InterVideo’s WinDVD. But overall, it’s a great bargain despite its few flaws.

Lenovo IdeaPad S10 Mini-Notebook
Faster than its mini-notebook brethren, the IdeaPad S10 offers enough perks to make it a top pick for serious mobility. The Lenovo S10 manages to pack a good deal of power and hard-drive capacity into its small frame.

Though using the S10 won’t match the luxurious tactile response of working with a ThinkPad, it is one of the better experiences among mini-notebooks.

At 3.6 pounds, the IdeaPad S10 is one of the heavier mini-notebooks on the market. But the Lenovo stands out for its relatively beefy specs, such as its 160GB hard disk.

This unit logged a score of 41 in our WorldBench 6 tests, a result that easily makes it the performance leader of this pack.

Asus Eee PC 1000H 80GB XP Mini-Notebook
Asus addresses most of the Eee family’s shortcomings with its newest–and biggest–mini-notebook. It approaches an ultraportable laptop in size and weight, but with half the power.

This hefty unit has a 10-inch display and weighs 3.6 pounds, in part because of the system’s 80GB hard disk and six-cell battery.

The 1000H also has a great keyboard, probably the best in the entire mini-notebook category.

The 1000H’s performance, however, will snap you back to reality, as it is no fully baked ultraportable. The system received a score of 37 on our WorldBench 6 tests, just a point higher than the MSI Wind managed.

Dell Inspiron Mini 9 Mini-Notebook
Dell’s dainty Inspiron Mini 9 looks as if someone left a standard laptop in the dryer too long. Our test configuration included an 8GB solid-state drive stuffed with Windows XP Home and preinstalled software such as Microsoft Works; about 1GB remained free. You should pay the extra $40 for an 16GB drive.

In our battery tests, the Mini lasted about 3 hours, 34 minutes with its four-cell battery. But in our WorldBench 6 suite, the Inspiron Mini 9 mustered an abysmal score of 25.

If big keys are all you care about, this little laptop has incredibly oversize keys that make typing a breeze.

MSI Wind NB U100 Mini-Notebook
MSI’s Wind is a hardy, if vanilla, mini-notebook; for the Windows XP faithful, it offers enough oomph for the job.
MSI’s Wind is probably closest to the Asus Eee PC 1000H: It has the same specs and hard drive, and a similar but slightly smaller design.

The keyboard is small but usable, a sturdy single bar covers the two mouse buttons, and the chassis feels sturdy, too.

The problem is that the Wind offers no real differentiators to justify its price, which is $50 higher than that of the Asus mini-notebook.

Would you recommend this article?

Share

Thanks for taking the time to let us know what you think of this article!
We'd love to hear your opinion about this or any other story you read in our publication.


Jim Love, Chief Content Officer, IT World Canada

Featured Download

Related Tech News

Get ITBusiness Delivered

Our experienced team of journalists brings you engaging content targeted to IT professionals and line-of-business executives delivered directly to your inbox.