iPad 2 or not iPad 2? That’s the tablet buying question

Simple, portable, user-friendly, and affordable. Say hello to the device of the future: a PC and smartphone rolled into one – the tablet.
The world of computing is at a crossroads. The primary computer for most users today is no longer a PC; it’s a phone. While your main machine sits on a desk either at the office or at home, smartphones go everywhere with us and integrate into every part of our daily lives. But despite getting increasingly smarter, phones are too small to replace PCs completely. We need a device that bridges the gap between computers and mobile phones. That device has arrived. Welcome to the age of the tablet.

Unlike earlier, arguably premature efforts to transform tablet computing into a mass-market reality, today’s models are here to stay. The new wave of slate devices is rolling in fast and furious, offering a wave of diverse options.

Related Slideshow: 8 iPad productivity tools you need to have

The concept of the tablet PC itself isn’t new, but its definition has radically changed. What we used to call a tablet was just a laptop with a touchscreen that swivelled around and folded back, yielding a bulky machine that was uncomfortable to carry and awkward to use as a laptop. That unsatisfactory hybrid was simply where the state of technology took us in previous efforts to create ‘tablet’ or ‘slate’ computers.

Things shifted thanks to advances in smartphone technology and the influence of Apple’s design team. When the Apple iPad hit the market last year, critics quickly dubbed it a giant Apple iPhone without the phone. That description speaks to the technology that makes possible its appealing dimensions, but it does not do it justice. In fact, the iPad altered everything we thought we knew about tablets, and other hardware manufacturers and Google with its Google Android system, are following up on Apple’s success quickly with a range of similar, but different (and in some cases, cheaper) devices.

Today’s tablet is exactly what the name implies: a thin slab, dominated by its screen. These slender systems generally max out at 750g, and few of them take up more space in your bag than a regular book would.

More importantly: the software for tablets has changed. Instead of struggling to run a full-fledged version of Windows, which requires a significant amount of processing power and isn’t optimised for use with a touchscreen, most new tablet models released nowadays run a relatively lightweight, touchscreen-focused mobile operating system such as Apple iOS or Google Android.

In 2011, we are set to see an astounding array of new tablets, including offerings from every major computer and phone maker, in many different sizes.

As yet, few rules constrain this burgeoning category, so you should expect to encounter a multitude of assorted designs, ranging from tiny slates that are barely distinguishable from phones to devices that rival netbooks in size and power. The most popular tablet so far is the Apple iPad, now in its second incarnation (showing just what a lead Apple had in this market).

Related Slideshow: Apple iPad 2’s top new features

The iPad 2 measures 241mm by 185mm and is a mere 8.8mm thick. It sports a 9.7in screen. Because the Apple iPad 2 is about the size of a typical spiral-bound paper notebook, it looks and feels familiar to most users on an unconscious level.

But a number of new devices, including the Samsung Galaxy Tab and the upcoming BlackBerry PlayBook have challenged the notion that a large 10in tablet is ideal for mobile use. The 7in screens that these machines provide make them more portable than the iPad, and major wireless carriers are lining up to offer them with 3G service plans subsidising the up-front price of the device with the monthly payment.

As well as size you need to consider the operating system you will be running. The iPad 2 runs the latest version of iOS, Apple’s operating system used by the iPad, iPhone and iPod touch devices. Many other systems (including those made by Samsung and Motorola) run different versions of the Android operating system, devices that are 7in typically run the Android 2.2 (also known as Froyo) whereas the newer 10in devices run the more advanced Android 3.0 (known as Honeycomb). Exceptions to this rule are the HP TouchPad, which runs HP’s WebOS operating system and Research In Motion’s BlackBerry PlayBook which runs the company’s proprietary BlackBerry Tablet OS.

Before Apple released the iPad, most tablet PCs ran touch-enabled versions of Microsoft’s windows operating system. Devices like the Asus Eee PC Touch and the Dell Inspiron Duo combine a touchscreen experience with Windows 7; they look more like regular laptops, however, and the experience is more akin to a traditional PC than one of the tablets running a dedicated operating system.

At the same time, the market now has eBook readers such as the Amazon Kindle, which you might be tempted to think of as ‘tablet-lites’. These are very different devices to tablets, and feature screens that only update when you press a button; they are designed purely to display text and static images.
It’s too early to tell whether users and the industry will ultimately favour a particular size and format for tablets, and a lot of it depends on your own personal preferences. While 10in screens offer a nicer experience, especially when using on-screen keyboards, 7in screens fit more comfortably in bags and large pockets. And all of the operating systems have their own individual quirks.

For all the chaos and confusion that the first round of slates is sure to create, the new devices promise some pretty fantastic opportunities as well. Coupling the mobility and connectivity of a smartphone with elements of a laptop – in particular, larger screens, more-powerful processors, and room for more and better cameras, ports and accessories – tablets invite mobile users to discover lots of new things to do with them.

Just as the iPhone and other smartphones caused an explosion of rich, location-aware social media interaction that few industry prophets predicted, the arrival of a category of even more-powerful, more-versatile machines will undoubtedly spur another furious cycle of innovation in Web-connected activity. After all, most of these new tablets come equipped with a camera for snapshot photography and video, as well as a front-facing camera for video conferencing on a heretofore unimagined scale.

Aside from better cameras, the larger format of the tablet makes room for improved GPS components with more-powerful antennas, which should support new capabilities for location-based services such as Facebook Places, Foursquare, and Layar. In time, the coupling of massive, socially driven photo and video services will let users visit a destination, pull out a tablet to capture their own photos and videos, and then share that content dynamically.

Mobile gaming, meanwhile, will receive a shot in the arm from tablets. Both Apple’s App Store and Google’s Android Market already teem with high-definition 3D games such as EA’s Madden 11 and Firemint’s Real Racing. Multiplayer casual games like Air Hockey and Scrabble are drawing people together over tablets, and it’s only a matter of time before massively multiplayer online titles such as World of Warcraft find a home on slates as well. The room for advancement in mobile-app development is practically inconceivable at this early stage.

The new wave of tablets will finally bring the dream of always-connected devices to fruition. Many of these tablets offer both Wi-Fi and 3G connectivity, and are available on subsidised data contracts from mobile networks. At the present no mobile company is offering a combined data plan with your mobile phone and tablet, instead requiring you to purchase a separate SIM card for each device (effectively doubling the amount you pay for wireless data). However, you can use many phones now to create wireless hotspots and share the data connection from your mobile phone directly to the tablet.

Before we can celebrate our arrival at a magnificent tablet-driven future, however, the industry must surmount several serious technical obstacles. The most significant hurdles come in the form of the operating-system platforms themselves, along with the big software companies that make them.

The stakes couldn’t be higher for the software giants. There’s ample reason to doubt that more than a few major platforms can thrive in the tablet marketplace over the long haul, a point that Apple, Google and Microsoft are keenly aware of as they spar over patent rights and internet standards in hopes of achieving tablet supremacy. The availability of apps on the contending platforms will be a key factor in this fight.

Even as the platform makers fight among themselves, each presents a unique set of features. Apple’s opaque and restrictive policies with regard to app approval remain a disincentive for many iOS developers, who may spend months developing an app only for Apple to refuse distribution on its store. And its refusal to allow adult and objectionable content on its app store smacks of nannying to many a paying customer. However, Apple keeps a close eye on all software, so as-of-yet viruses and malware are non-existent on the iPad, which makes it a tempting proposition for many a consumer weary of endlessly updating anti-virus programs and security updates.

Google has a more free-for-all approach, although it does check apps for malicious content. You can, however, install any program even if Google hasn’t checked it, through a process called ‘side-loading’, though you will have to enable this feature in the Settings first. The fragmentation of Android devices with different hardware makes it difficult for app creators to support the growing variety of screen sizes and hardware specs that Android comprehends.

For its part, Windows 7 isn’t optimised for touch control as Android and iOS are, and that deficiency will make it harder for users to select appropriate software to use on their Windows 7 tablets.

And developers now find that there are two new operating systems: HP’s WebOS and BlackBerry’s Tablet OS to contend with. Whatever the features these devices sport, they may find it hard to convince developers to move their focus away from Apple and Google, and we’d wager both their app stores will remain lighter than Apple’s and Google’s for some time. In the meantime, developers will have to work overtime to port their apps across multiple hardware and software platforms – an undertaking that is fraught with unpleasant challenges – as they try to reach as many users as possible.

But why get a tablet at all? Surely the laptop provides most, if not all of the functions available on a tablet. The key isn’t what tablets do, it’s how they do things. Typically a tablet will do fewer things than a laptop, in many cases far fewer; but they do things in a much better manner. The idea has been to focus on the few things people want: Web browsing, email, Facebook, photos and videos, and to do these things in a simplified manner that makes tablets a joy to use.
Mobile Web browsing is generally much more satisfying: If what you want to do is read the latest news on your favourite sites, you’ll discover that ditching the touchpad and keyboard of a standard laptop in favour of a spacious touchscreen will enable you to swipe and tap your way effortlessly around the net.

Reading and responding to email is also largely satisfying because – like smartphones – these devices have persistent data connection, ensuring that your messages are there whenever you switch on, wherever you switch on. Typing with a virtual on-screen keyboard instead of a real set of keys is a different experience, however, and tablets are typically suited to short messages rather than long written articles. While it’s possible to create and work with documents, including Microsoft Office ones, tablets aren’t ideal for any kind of work that requires a lot of key pressing (they are great for presentations though).

Reading books – particularly in the dark, where paper books and E-Ink-based readers alike tend to fail without the aid of external lighting attachments – can be a joy on a good tablet. Amazon’s Kindle app, and Kobo.com’s eBooks app all support multiple OS and device platforms, so you can begin reading on one device, put it down, and move to another device without losing your place.

Watching video on a tablet is a great way to unwind during a long flight without having to park a netbook or laptop on your tray table. And when you’re connected via Wi-Fi, streaming services are awesome. Mobile email on a tablet is an order of magnitude easier to manage than mobile email on a phone. Nevertheless, you won’t be tempted to write your next dissertation on a tablet’s on-screen keyboard: The amount of space viewable on the display shrinks considerably when you activate the on-screen keyboard, and the unfriendly ergonomics will soon have your back muscles crying out for a massage.

On the whole though, there’s no doubt that many people consider a tablet to be the must-have gadget of the moment. Apple sold 14 million iPads in the first year, and Motorola, Samsung, HP and BlackBerry all hope to have similar levels of success this year that’s a lot of love for touchscreen tablets.

Tablets offer a new kind of computing experience: they switch on instantly, enable you to browse the internet, send emails and use apps while holding it in your hand and there’s little of the complexity of computers, and few worries about viruses and malicious software. There’s a lot of reasons to love tablets, and there are plenty of great models to choose from.

On the computing side of things choosing an operating system is pretty simple: either you get a Windows PC or you opt for a Mac. In the tablet world, however, there are at least five different platforms vying for your attention. Apple’s iOS, which powers the iPad 2, iPhone and iPod touch, currently leads the pack, thanks to its compatibility with a massive selection of more than 300,000 apps.

Google Android is, however, on the march. The platform behind the majority of non-Apple tablet offerings, it will be available on more than a dozen major releases in 2011. Current tablets offer Android versions 1.6, 2.0, 2.1 and 2.2, but the one to watch out for is Android 3.0 (also known as Honeycomb). This will be available on the newer 10in tablets such as the Motorola Xoom. Android has slightly better multitasking than Apple’s iOS, and it’s a more open system with a wider range of apps.

Research in Motion has entered the fray with its BlackBerry Tablet OS, which will debut on its BlackBerry PlayBook. One quirk is that it only works in horizontal format, but it’s a smooth interface and promises integration with BlackBerry Messenger software.

HP will be launching WebOS with its TouchPad. This offers a slick interface that makes it easy to work on multiple items at once. It also offers close integration to all of HP’s other products (such as printers) and a host of apps will be available.

In among all this Microsoft continues to advance Windows 7, although it’s not a bespoke tablet OS and is really better suited to laptops.

If you have already sworn allegiance to one platform or another, your choice could be an easy one. But if you prefer to base your decision on a careful comparison of features and utility, the coming barrage of tablet operating systems could make the old Windows/Mac platform war look like a teddy bear’s picnic. Apple iPad and Google Android tablets are the safe bets; WebOS and BlackBerry Tablet OS are the more esoteric options.

Would you recommend this article?


Thanks for taking the time to let us know what you think of this article!
We'd love to hear your opinion about this or any other story you read in our publication.

Jim Love, Chief Content Officer, IT World Canada

Featured Download

Featured Story

How the CTO can Maintain Cloud Momentum Across the Enterprise

Embracing cloud is easy for some individuals. But embedding widespread cloud adoption at the enterprise level is...

Related Tech News

Get ITBusiness Delivered

Our experienced team of journalists brings you engaging content targeted to IT professionals and line-of-business executives delivered directly to your inbox.

Featured Tech Jobs