Chip-card technology may be a mixed blessing for small Canadian merchants

As Canadian merchants begin to accept chip-based payment cards they can expect to see a reduction in fraud.

But merchants who don’t make the switch by October 2010, would also accept more liability for fraud , according to Visa Canada Inc.

Visa announced it would start replacing its magnetic stripe cards with a microchip-based card in 2003. Those have now started rolling out, being issued to consumers as replacement cards. The process, which began last Fall and will continue over the next several years.

The basic difference for consumers is that instead of swiping you card and signing a slip of paper, you now insert your card into a reader and enter a PIN to authorize a transaction.

But for merchants, who accept Visa as a form of payment, the new chip cards come with a bit more baggage. Not switching over to a chip-based Point of Sales (POS) machine could mean a merchant accepting the liability for potential credit card fraud that exploits older magnetic stripe cards. Improper use of the card by untrained staff could also result in fines.

Visa Chip card

It’s all in the effort to eliminate payment card fraud – the primary responsibility of everyone involved in a card-based transaction, according to Gord Jamieson, head of payment system risk at Visa Canada.

“This is the shared responsibility of everyone involved in the payment scheme,” he says. “From the consumer that has the card right down to the merchant accepting it and law enforcement.”

Payment card fraud in Canada totalled a whopping $511 million in 2008. That figure has growth alarmingly over the years — it was $240 million in 2006 and $60 million in 2002.

About half of the fraud is due to counterfeit cards being produced using stolen magnetic stripe data.

“That’s seed money being used by criminal organizations and terrorist groups to fund other activities they’re involved in,” Jamieson says.

The chip-based card is supposed to stop that. Its security features are tough to crack – “impossible” according to Jamieson, and very tough to break according to industry observers.

“It’s much, much, harder to counterfeit,” says Rob Burbach, senior analyst, financial insights at IDC Canada in Toronto. “There’s no evidence to show anyone has broken the chip card code yet, but that doesn’t mean it hasn’t happened.”

Canada lags behind some European and Pacific countries that have already deployed the chip card. But it is ahead of the U.S. in rolling out the tougher security technology.

Payment card fraud tends to shift away from countries that move to chip cards, as fraudsters target the magnetic stripe cards used in other countries, says Catherine Johnson, the president of Advanced Card Technologies (ACT) Canada.

Based in Ajax, Ont. ACT’s mandate is to promote awareness, understanding and use of advanced card technologies across a wide range of applications.

“Some of the fraud has already started to move,” Johnson says. “There’s higher credit card fraud in the U.S. now.”

Even chip-based cards still have a magnetic stripe on the back.

Visa and other card providers understand that not all countries will be able to make the shift at once, nor will all the merchants in one country. So the stripe remains as a back-up to the chip, Jamieson says. But merchants are expected to support chip-based cards by October 2010.

“If as a business, you decide not to not put a chip terminal in your location, and there’s a magnetic strip card that’s compromised, you as the merchant will be responsible for that fraud,” he says.

With only 18 months left until the liability shift, many small businesses may find themselves liable without realizing it, says Catherine Swift, president of the Canadian Federation of Independent Businesses that represents the interests of small and mid-sized businesses in every sector.

“We’re not crazy about it, particularly from a small merchant standpoint,” she says. “You can’t just snap your fingers to get the new technology you need to be totally in-sync, that costs money.”

Given a tough economy, Swift wonders if a grace period might be allowed by Visa instead of a hard deadline. She’s also concerned that it will be tough to inform small business operators about the new policy, and some will be surprised to find they’re on the hook for an expensive fraud charge.

“This is the kind of thing they don’t focus on until they’re right up against it,” she says.

Some smaller merchants will be informed by their payment acquirer of the need to switch over, Burbach says. But others may be surprised by how much fraud does occur, and may not fully grasp the risk involved in not adopting the new technology.

“They need to figure out ways to reach out to small merchants that are convenient to them,” he says. “Holding events in centralized locations probably ain’t gonna cut it.”

Visa held several events across Canada that aimed to inform small businesses about the new technology. At a recent event in Toronto, about 20 people showed up.

Would you recommend this article?


Thanks for taking the time to let us know what you think of this article!
We'd love to hear your opinion about this or any other story you read in our publication.

Jim Love, Chief Content Officer, IT World Canada

Featured Download

Brian Jackson
Brian Jackson
Editorial director of IT World Canada. Covering technology as it applies to business users. Multiple COPA award winner and now judge. Paddles a canoe as much as possible.

Related Tech News

Get ITBusiness Delivered

Our experienced team of journalists brings you engaging content targeted to IT professionals and line-of-business executives delivered directly to your inbox.